The Croydon Astronomical Society

Updated

The Great Debate !

Who was The Greatest Astronomer of all Time ?

13th January 2008

The results of the vote are in !

Position

Number of Votes

Astronomer

Champion

1

7

Isaac Newton

Helen Shaw

2

5

Edwin Hubble

Geoff Keir

2

5

Ptolemy of Alexandria

Mike Ross

4

3

Caroline Herschel

Paul Harper

4

3

William Huggins

John Murrell

6

2

William Herschel

Konrad Malin-Smith

7

1

Charles Messier

Alan Drummond

Congratulations to Isaac Newton & his champion Helen Shaw.

Thanks to all those who took part

John Murrell

 

 

Brahe ? ,Newton ?, Hipparcos ?, or Perryman ?

Following The BBC’s search for ‘The Greatest Britain’ of all time we have decided to find ‘The Greatest Astronomer of all time’.

Galileo ? , Beg ?, Hershel ? or Hale ?

On Friday 14th March 2003 we will be holding our Great Debate at The Royal Russell school to decide who is the Greatest Astronomer of all Time.

 

Khayyam ?, Hubble ?, Al-Battani ? or Alcock ?

Will your favourite win ? We are looking for volunteers to put the case for who you believe is The Greatest Astronomer of all time. The current list of candidates for ‘The Greatest Astronomer of all time’ is at the bottom of the page together with the champion who has volunteered to speak for them.

 

Ptolomy ?, Copernicous ?, Ptobio ? or Abdullah ?

Each speaker will have a strictly limited time to put the case for their candidate – this will be about 100 minutes divided by the number of speakers. Only one speaker will be allowed to speak for each astronomer.

 

 

Leavitt?, Carrington ?, Huggins ? or Wolszczan ?

If your candidate for ‘The Greatest Astronomer of all Time’ is not in the list below there is no chance in them winning unless you volunteer to speak for them. Where more than one person volunteers to speak for the same astronomer the sender of the first EMAIL received will be given priority. To ensure that your choice becomes The Greatest Astronomer of all Time volunteer now to speak about them on the 14th March 2003 by sending an EMAIL to TheGreatDebate@CroydonAstro.org.uk.  Do it NOW

 

Halley ?, Green ? Rosse ? or Lowell ?

Astronomer

Champion

Reservation Date

Caroline Herschel

Paul Harper

16th November 2002

William Herschel

Konrad Malin-Smith

26th November 2002

Sir William Huggins

John Murrell

6th January 2003

Edwin Hubble

Geoff Keir

21st January 2003

Isaac Newton

Helen Shaw

20th January 2003

Charles Messier

Alan Drummond

 

Ptolemy of Alexandria

Mike Ross